Title
Applicant Appeal of Trecinto Project (Z25-091) [Noticed 10/09/2026; Published 10/09/2026]
End
FileID
File ID: 2026-01847
End
Location
Location: 7615 Jacinto Road, APN 117-0202-025-0000, District 8
End
Recommendation
Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing and upon conclusion, pass a Motion to: 1) close the public hearing; and 2) approve: a) Environmental Exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines sections 15332, (In-Fill Development); b) Tentative Map to subdivide a ±2.4-acre parcel into 29 parcels within the Single-Unit Dwelling (R-1-R) zone; c) Site Plan and Design Review to review the tentative map layout with deviations to minimum lot width and depth and to construct 29 single-unit dwellings, with deviations to lot size, width, depth, building setback, and lot coverage standards; and d) Tree Permit for the removal of one private protected tree.
End
Contact
Contact: Michael Crampton, Assistant Planner, (916) 808-8951, mcrampton@cityofsacramento.org; Marcus Adams, Senior Planner, (916) 808-5044, madams@cityofsacramento.org; Community Development Department
End
Presenter
Presenter: Michael Crampton, Assistant Planner, (916) 808-8951, mcrampton@cityofsacramento.org, Community Development Department
End
Applicant
Applicant: Andrew MacDonald, Cartwright NorCal, Inc., 3010 Lava Ridge Court, Suite 160, Roseville, CA 95661, (916) 978-4001, andrewm@cartwrightengineers.com
End
Property Owner
Property Owner: Donnie Hanly, NGC Trecinto, LLC., 2339 Gold Meadow Way #205, Gold River, CA 95670, (916) 822-3220, dhanly@nextgenerationcapital.us
End
Attachments
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Background
3-Findings of Fact and Conditions of Approval
4-Project Plans
5-Applicant Appeal Letter
6-Applicant Appeal Supplemental
7-Letter of Opposition
8-Historic Evaluation Report
9-Arborist Report
10-Staff Presentation
11-Applicant Presentation
End
Description/Analysis
IssueDetail
Issue Detail: The 2.4-acre Trecinto project site is located north of Jacinto Road between Bruceville and Ardennes Way in the Shasta Neighborhood in South Sacramento. The site is currently developed with a single unit dwelling and is surrounded by single-unit dwellings on large lots, with newer residential development to the south and east. The site is located within ½ mile from the Consumnes River College Light Rail Station.
The site is located within the Single-Unit Dwelling (R-1-R) Zone. The purpose of the R-1 zone is to accommodate low-density residential uses composed of single-unit detached residences and duplex dwellings on corner lots. This zone may also include recreational, religious, and educational facilities as the basic elements of a balanced neighborhood.
This project requires the following entitlements:
1. Tentative Map to subdivide a ±2.4-acre parcel into 29 parcels within the Single-Unit Dwelling (R-1-R) zone.
2. Site Plan and Design Review to review the demolition of the existing single-unit dwelling as well as the construction of 29 single-unit dwellings and associated site improvements. Deviations to minimum lot size, width, and depth as well as setback and lot coverage standards are requested.
3. Tree Permit. The project requires a Tree Permit entitlement for the removal of one private protected tree that conflicts with the location of the proposed buildings.
Director Hearing: On August 6, 2026, the Zoning Administrator and Design Director held a public hearing and partially approved the project. The Zoning Administrator approved the entitlements for Environmental Exemption and Tentative Map, and the Design Director approved the entitlement for the Tree Permit and denied the entitlement for Site Plan and Design Review. The Applicant has appealed the decision; the appeal was timely filed on August 13, 2026. The basis for the appeal is discussed below and is available in Attachments 5 and 6.
The Design Director’s denial of the Site Plan and Design Review entitlement was based on findings that the project is inconsistent with the General Plan policies listed below and that the deviations do not meet the purpose and intent of the development standards. In sum, the Design Director found that the granting of the proposed deviations would result in a project that is not consistent with the General Plan’s emphasis on prioritizing pedestrians, alternative modes of transportation, and the provision of adequate green space and tree canopy:
1. Policy LUP-2.2 (Interconnected City): The City should establish a network of interconnected activity centers, corridors, parks, and neighborhoods that promotes walking, bicycling, and mass transit use as viable alternatives to private vehicles.
2. Policy LUP-2.5 (Design for Connectivity): The City shall require that all new development maximizes existing and new connections with surroundings and with centers, corridors, parks, and neighborhoods to enhance efficient and direct pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicle movement. When feasible, grid patterns should be utilized to facilitate multiple routes.
3. Policy M-1.1 (Street Classification System): The City shall maintain a street classification system that considers the role of streets as corridors for movement but prioritizes a context-sensitive Complete Streets concept that enables connected, comfortable, and convenient travel for those walking, rolling, and taking transit.
4. Policy M-1.2 (User Prioritization): The City shall prioritize mobility, comfort, health, safety, and convenience for those walking, followed by those bicycling and riding transit, ahead of design and operations for those driving.
5. Policy M-1.5 (Street Design Standards): The City shall maintain street design and operations standards that prioritize comfort and travel time for walking, bicycling, and transit, while managing vehicle speeds and traffic volumes, updating them as best practices evolve.
6. Policy M-1.11 (Increase Bicycling and Walking): The City shall strive to increase bicycling and walking citywide so that it can meet its equity, reduced vehicle miles traveled, and sustainability goals.
7. Policy M-1.13 (Walkability): The City shall design streets to prioritize walking by including design elements such as the following:
• Grid networks that provide high levels of connectivity;
• Closely spaced intersections;
• Frequent and low-stress crossings;
• Wide, unobstructed walkable sidewalks;
• Separation from vehicle traffic;
• Street trees that provide shading; and
• Minimal curb cuts.
8. Policy M-1.14 (Walking Facilities): The City shall work to complete the network of tree-shaded sidewalks throughout the city, to the greatest extent feasible, by building new sidewalks and crossings, especially within the high-injury network, in disadvantaged communities, near high-ridership transit stops, and near important destinations, such as schools, parks, and commercial areas. Walking facilities should incorporate shade trees.
9. Policy M-1.15 (Improve Walking Connectivity): The City shall require new subdivisions, new multiunit dwelling developments, and new developments along commercial corridors to include well-lit, tree-shaded walkways where feasible, that provide direct links to the public realm or adjacent public destinations such as transit stops and stations, schools, parks, and shopping centers.
10. Policy M-3.1 (Local Streets): The City shall provide a slow speed network of local-serving neighborhood streets. Existing street trees should be maintained and replaced, new trees installed where feasible, and street trees should be incorporated into new neighborhood streets.
11. Policy ERC-3.4 (Private Streets): The City shall, when private streets are approved, require inclusion of trees unless clearly infeasible. If street trees are not feasible, locations within the development should be identified for inclusion of green space and tree canopy.
Housing Accountability Act: The Housing Accountability Act (HAA) limits local governments’ ability to disapprove, condition, or reduce the density of housing development projects, emergency shelters, or farmworker housing that is consistent with local objective development standards and contribute to meeting housing needs.
After an application is determined to be complete, local agencies have a set time limit to inform the applicant in writing if the project proposal is inconsistent with objective general plan, zoning, subdivision, and design standards and criteria; otherwise, the application is deemed consistent by default. Consistency review for projects containing 150 or fewer units are limited to 30 days from the date a project application is determined to be complete.
Planning staff provided a completeness letter to the applicant on December 22, 2025, within 30 days of the project being determined to be accepted. The letter identified the project was not consistent with maximum lot coverage, minimum lot size, width, depth, and minimum setback (front-, side-, and rear-yard) standards. Based on the content of the letter, the project is not required to comply with bulk control, standard street sections, or street frontage requirements. A housing development proposal that is consistent cannot be disapproved or approved with a condition that reduces the density of the project unless the jurisdiction makes both of the following findings:
Finding #1. Specific, Adverse Impact on Public Health or Safety. That the proposed development would have a “specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density.” Specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and
Finding #2. No Possible Mitigation. That “there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.”
Staff does not find that evidence of a specific, adverse impact upon public health or safety exists. The project has been reviewed and conditions placed on the project to ensure safe development standards are met.
Appeal Detail: The basis of the applicant’s appeal can be broadly categorized into three justifications provided below.
1) Denial was based on aspects of the project that were protected under State Law;
2) Findings of fact for denial of the Site Plan and Design Review entitlement though stated by the Zoning Administrator and concurred by the Design Director at the Director Hearing, were based on subjective, rather than the objective Housing Accountability Act finding that a housing development proposal which meets city objective criteria and is deemed complete cannot be disapproved or approved with a condition that reduces the density of the project unless there is a “specific adverse impact on public health or safety.”
3) The project advances policies outlined in the 2040 General Plan.
Staff’s recommendation to approve the project has not changed. Staff recommend the Planning and Design Commission approve the project, as conditioned, and believe that the project meets the overall goals and objectives of the General Plan.
Streets and Pedestrian Improvements: Additional right-of-way would be dedicated on the north side of Jacinto Road for the construction of curb, gutter, tree planter, and a separated sidewalk in front of the property, as none currently exists. The project will dedicate a new section of Ardennes Way as a public, 53-foot wide street that will eventually connect to the existing portion of Ardennes Way to the east, and Gimron Way to the west. A 20-foot roadway will connect Jacinto Road and Ardennes Way, providing pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicle access to homes fronting onto the street.
Tree Canopy: Street trees are not feasible within the reduced right-of-way, however alternate locations are identified within the project area for greenspace and tree canopy. Requiring trees in the front yard with comparable tree canopy as shade trees meets the stated intention of 2040 General Plan Policy ERC-3.4.
1. With the exception of corner lots with expanded street side yards, all lots provide a 15-20’ front yard setbacks where tree species will be planted with a height and width of up to 30 feet at full maturity.
2. Conditions require at least one tree within the front-yard and street-side setback area.
End
Public/Neighborhood Outreach and Comments: Staff routed the proposal to community groups within 500 feet of the site including: Civic Thread, Sacramento Area Bicycle Advocates, Preservation Sacramento, North Laguna Creek Valley Hi Community Association and North Laguna Creek Neighborhood Association. These community groups as well as property owners and current residents/businesses within 500 feet of the project site were sent a notice of the October 22, 2026 Planning and Design Commission meeting. Staff received one public comment letter expressing concern about the project, included as Attachment 7. Below is a summary of the concerns identified in the letter of opposition followed by staff responses.
1. The proposed density and request to for deviations to lot size, setback, and lot coverage standards will reduce privacy, block sunlight and outdoor views.
Staff Response: While staff recognizes the preference for fewer units, the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) is a State law that limits the ability of the city to deny, reduce the density of, or impose infeasible restrictions on housing development unless findings can be made that the project would have “a specific adverse impact on public health or safety,” and that there is “no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.” Staff does not find a basis for such a finding. The 2040 General Plan does not provide a maximum density for development of this parcel, and the parcel is consistent with the density requirements of the R-1 zone. As such, the project cannot be required to reduce its density as it is consistent with the objective density standards of the General Plan and underlying R-1 zone.
The project’s request for deviations to setbacks and lot coverage reduces the individual open space available for each home, however the project site’s proximity to Jacinto Creek Park and Shasta Community Park (0.5 and 0.7 miles/11 and 16 minute walk respectively) provide several options for open space within walking and biking distance. Sufficient building setbacks are provided to meet building code requirements for separation between structures and provide a small rear yard space for residents along with landscaped areas in the front of each home.
2. The existing infrastructure is not able to handle the traffic and parking challenges that the proposed project will generate.
Staff Response: The project was evaluated by the City’s Department of Public Works and conditioned to construct the necessary right-of-way improvements for on-street parking on the north portion of Jacinto Road and along both sides of Ardennes Way. While no on-street parking is provided along the proposed private drive, the project was revised to include a standard parking pad in front of each garage, providing 2 vehicle spaces (for homes with a single-car garage) or 4 vehicle spaces (for homes with a two-car garage). While there is no minimum parking requirement for the project, staff believes sufficient parking is provided.
3. The removal of one private protected tree will damage the local landscape.
Staff Response: The project proposes the removal of 25 trees, including one private protected tree (identified as tree #3062 in the attached arborist report). After review of the project and arborist report, Urban Forestry supports the removal of the private protected tree as it conflicts with the most reasonable placement of buildings and because its health and condition would make it unlikely to survive construction or to provide sustainable shade benefit to the new development.
4. The proposed density will lead to overcrowding of the community and overburden local public facilities including drainage systems and city utilities.
Staff Response: The project was reviewed by various departments and agencies and the project is conditioned to provide the necessary infrastructure to support existing and future utility infrastructure. For example, the Department of Utilities (DOU) has conditioned the project to prepare a project specific water study to be reviewed and approved by DOU; to install water and utility infrastructure to the satisfaction of DOU; and to form an HOA or privately funded maintenance district. Staff believes these conditions address concerns this project may have related to existing or future utility and drainage infrastructure.
PolicyConsiderations
Policy Considerations:
General Plan
The 2040 General Plan designation for the project site is Residential Mixed Use (RMU), which is intended to foster vibrant, walkable areas with a high-intensity mix of residential, commercial, office, and public uses, where daily errands can be accomplished on foot, by bicycle, or by transit. The RMU designation promotes housing mixed with retail and other community-serving uses to catalyze infill development of vacant and underutilized parcels. Allowable uses include a full range of residential, retail, employment, entertainment, cultural, and personal service uses serving a communitywide market, such as restaurants, apparel stores, specialty shops, theaters, bookstores, hotels and motels, and research and development facilities.
The project is consistent with the RMU designation as it facilitates the redevelopment of a large, underutilized residential parcel with higher-density single-unit residential development in a neighborhood close to transportation corridors and transit options. In addition to the project’s consistency with the RMU designation, the project is also consistent with the following goals and policies from the 2040 General Plan:
Goal LUP-1. A compact urban footprint and sustainable development pattern with infrastructure that supports efficient delivery of public services while protecting surrounding open space lands.
LUP-1.1 Compact Urban Footprint. The City shall promote a land- and resource-efficient development pattern and the placement of infrastructure to support efficient delivery of public services and conserve open space, reduce vehicle miles traveled, and improve air quality.
Goal LUP-2. Balanced and connected community with thriving neighborhoods and centers and development intensities linked to transit.
LUP 2.4 Development Intensity Linked to Transit. The City shall plan for higher development intensities around current and planned transit to optimize public investments and support an accessible, convenient network.
Goal LUP-6. A city of healthy, livable, “complete neighborhoods” that provide for residents’ daily needs within easy walking or biking distance from home.
LUP-6.2 Range of Residential Development Intensities. The City shall allow for a range of residential development intensities throughout the community to cultivate a mix of housing types at varying sales price points and rental rates, provide options for residents of all income levels, and protect existing residents from displacement.
Goal H-1. Facilitate the construction of 45,580 new housing units by 2029.
H-1.4 Facilitate Infill Housing Development. The City shall facilitate infill housing along commercial corridors, near employment centers, near high-frequency transit areas, and in all zones that allow residential development as a way to revitalize commercial corridors, promote walkability and increased transit ridership, and provide increased housing options.
Staff Response: The project is consistent with the goals and policies above in that the project facilitates infill development by redeveloping an underutilized parcel with a higher-density single-unit residential development close to existing transportation corridors and transit options. The proposed density (13.2 du/na) exceeds the 2040 General Plan’s minimum density designation (3 du/na); an increased density is consistent with General Plan policies to optimize public investments in transit by supporting higher development intensities around current and planned transit. Supporting a broad range of housing, including single-unit dwellings on small lots, is identified within the 2040 General Plan as a foundation for providing homeownership opportunities for residents of varying income levels, supporting efficient delivery of public services, reducing vehicle miles travelled, and improving air quality.
200-Year Flood Protection
State Law (SB 5) and Planning and Development Code chapter 17.810 require that the City must make specific findings prior to approving certain entitlements for projects within a flood hazard zone. The project site is not located within a flood hazard zone as defined by section 17.108.070 of the city code.
End
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Environmental Considerations: The Community Development Department, Environmental Planning Services has reviewed this project and determined that it is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines section 15332, Infill Development (Categorical Exemption - Class 32). Class 15332 consists of projects consistent with applicable GP LU designation and zoning regulations, on parcels within city limits on no more than 5-acres, where the site has no value as habitat for rare, threatened, or endangered species, and approval of the project would not result in any significant effects related to traffic, noise, air, or water quality.
End
RationaleforRecommendation
Rationale for Recommendation: Staff recommends the Planning and Design Commission approve the project, thereby approving the Applicant’s appeal, based on the findings of fact and subject to the conditions of approval listed in Attachment 3. Staff’s recommendation is based on the findings that the project: a) is consistent with the established goals and implementing policies within the RMU designation, and meets the goals and intention of the R-1-R zone; b) is compatible with surrounding uses in the neighborhood; c) will not negatively impact surrounding properties as conditioned; and d) promotes sustainable growth and change by facilitating the infill development of a large, underutilized property with a higher-density single-unit dwelling development.
End
FinancialConsiderations
Financial Considerations: Not applicable.
End
LocalBusinessEnterprise
Local Business Enterprise (LBE): No goods or services are being purchased under this report.
End
Economic Impacts
Economic Impacts: Not applicable.
End
Sustainability
Sustainability: Not applicable.
End