Title
Appeal of the Disqualification of Miguel Jurado from the Street Construction Laborer Recruitment
End
FileID
File ID: 2026-01994
End
Location
Location: Citywide
End
Recommendation
Recommendation: Pass a Motion 1) waiving formal rules for conducting the hearing pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4.11(c)(7), and 2) adopting the Director’s findings, determinations, and decision of disqualification in the appeal of Miguel Jurado for the Street Construction Laborer Recruitment pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4.11(c)(6).
End
Contact
Contact: Juanita Salazar, Personnel Analyst, (916) 808-5944, jsalazar@cityofsacramento.org, Human Resources Department
End
Presenter
Presenter: None
End
Attachments
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Job Announcement
3-Applicant’s Application
4-Notice of Disqualification
5-Appeal from Applicant
6-Calculation of Qualifying Experience
End
Description/Analysis
IssueDetail
Issue Detail:
BACKGROUND
A job announcement for Street Construction Laborer posted on September 22, 2026 (Attachment 2). On September 23, 2026, Miguel Jurado submitted a timely application (Attachment 3) for the posting. On October 15, 2026, Appellant Jurado received a notice of disqualification (Attachment 4) stating the application did not meet the qualifications under the “Experience and Education” portion of the job announcement.
ISSUE RAISED BY APPELLANT
On October 16, 2026, Appellant Jurado submitted an appeal response (Attachment 5) to the disqualification, citing Civil Service Board (CSB) Rule 4.10(c)(1): Erroneous interpretation or application of the qualification standards prescribed for the classification. Appellant Jurado’s appeal states in part:
“In my application I input all of my previous 5 years of construction work experience, as well as the 2 years I have spent as a street construction trainee for the city….
I also stated at the bottom of the application that I have taken four or more relevant, formal training courses or programs’ as well as ‘an additional two or more years of relevant experience as required by this job posting….
Therefore I would like to appeal on the grounds of (1) Erroneous interpretation of application of qualification standards prescribed for classification, given that I have exceeded the qualifications for both education and work experience for this position….
I have worked at the city for two years as a trainee and I have done everything to promote to the laborer position."
CITY’S RESPONSE TO APPEAL
The City contends the qualification standards prescribed for the classification were correctly applied to Appellant Jurado, and they do not meet the qualification standards as stated in the job announcement. The City responds to each item raised by Appellant Jurado, respectively, as follows:
I. The minimum qualifications for the classification that Appellant Jurado applied to are as follows:
Two years of experience operating medium street construction and maintenance equipment and performing skilled heavy manual street construction, maintenance, and repair duties.
OR
Two years of experience comparable to a Street Construction Laborer Trainee with the City of Sacramento.
II. The City interprets and consistently applies the minimum qualifications to mean:
Two years of experience operating medium street construction and maintenance equipment which may include dump trucks, water tank trucks, front-end loaders, spreaders, pavement rollers, tractors, distributor trucks, and other similar equipment. In addition, applicants must possess two years of experience performing skilled heavy manual street construction, maintenance, and repair duties. Such duties may include spreading asphaltic road building material over road surface; repairing and patching curbs, gutters, bridge decks, headwalls, sidewalks, and related concrete work; and/or making minor field repairs and adjustments.
OR
Demonstration of two years of experience comparable to a Street Construction Laborer Trainee with the City of Sacramento. Examples of comparable duties include, but are not limited to, in a training capacity; spreading asphaltic road material; sealing road surfaces; repairing concrete; cleaning and adjusting service tools; setting up traffic barricades or warning signs; operating dump trucks, water trucks, front end loaders, spreaders, tractors, and/or pavement rollers; and operating a jackhammer and other pneumatic tools.
III. Appellant Jurado completed the Work Experience section of the application and listed employment with the City of Sacramento as a Trainee from January 1, 2025 to present. The duties listed included assisting with the demolition of ramps, cutting and removing concrete, setting ADA ramps to grade, and pouring and finishing concrete.
The duties provided demonstrate experience comparable to a Street Construction Laborer Trainee. However, when calculated through the final filing deadline of October 6, 2026, the employment dates listed on the application reflect 1.83 years (22 months) of qualifying experience, which is less than the required two years. Therefore, this employment did not satisfy the two years of experience required under the second minimum qualification pattern.
IV. Appellant Jurado also listed employment with Madera Construction as a Framer from September 2021 to October 2024. The duties listed included installing hardware, blocking, setting beams, reading blueprints, and interpreting them for workers. While this experience demonstrates general construction experience, the duties provided did not establish experience operating medium street construction and maintenance equipment or performing skilled heavy manual street construction, maintenance, and repair duties.
Additionally, the duties described did not demonstrate experience comparable to a Street Construction Laborer Trainee, such as street construction, street maintenance, road surface repairs, or operation of street construction equipment. Therefore, this employment did not provide additional qualifying experience under either minimum qualification pattern.
V. Appellant Jurado stated in their appeal they included five years of construction experience and two years of experience as a City trainee were documented in the application. However, applications are screened based on the information provided by the applicant in the duties area of the Work Experience section of the employment application. The City evaluates the nature of the duties performed and the duration of qualifying experience rather than relying solely on job titles or total years of employment.
Appellant Jurado answered "Yes" to understanding the supplemental question on the application (Attachment 3), which states that current and/or past job-related experience must be listed in the duties area of the Work Experience section and that qualifying experience is calculated based on full-time equivalent experience.

Although Appellant Jurado documented several years of employment, the duties provided did not demonstrate two full years of qualifying experience under either minimum qualification pattern.
VI. Appellant Jurado also referenced a bachelor's degree, completion of four or more relevant formal training courses or programs, and a supplemental questionnaire response indicating an additional two or more years of relevant experience. The minimum qualifications for the Street Construction Laborer classification require two years of qualifying experience under either of the stated patterns. The minimum qualifications do not provide a substitution pattern allowing for education or training to substitute for the required experience.
Additionally, responses to the supplemental questionnaire do not substitute for the information required in the Work Experience section of the application. Applicants must demonstrate the required experience through the duties and employment dates provided in the application.
VII. While Appellant Jurado provided additional statements regarding experience and qualifications in the appeal, additional information submitted after the final filing deadline of October 6, 2026, cannot be accepted or considered in determining minimum qualification eligibility, consistent with Civil Service Board Rule 4.2:
"Applicants for examinations must meet the qualification standards for the classification by the date set forth in the announcement. Any license requirements, however, shall be met at time of appointment."
Applications are evaluated based on the information provided in the Work Experience section of the application submitted before the final filing deadline. This requirement is also outlined in the Selection Procedure and Supplemental Questions sections of the job announcement (Attachment 2).
VIII. Based on the experience and duties documented in the application, Appellant Jurado failed to demonstrate that the minimum qualifications for the Street Construction Laborer classification were met.
Appellant Jurado may reapply in the future when the classification is recruited for again. Recruitments are conducted based on the operational needs of the department.
IX. The same evaluation standards prescribed for the classification were applied to all applicants.
As such, the Director of Human Resources recommends that the Board adopt the Director’s findings, determination, and decision of disqualification pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4.11(c)(6).
End
PolicyConsiderations
Policy Considerations: Civil Service Board Rule 4.3 Disqualification (a) Failure to meet any of the requirements or qualifications established for the examination, as published in the announcement. Appeals for disqualification shall be heard by the Board unless the Board requests and receives permission from the City Council to utilize the services of a hearing officer. (Civil Service Board Rule 4.11). When the Board hears the appeal itself, the Board may waive the formal rules of procedure in the interest of justice in individual cases and may adopt its own findings, determinations, and decision for adoption and incorporation into the official Board minutes. (Civil Service Board Rules 4.11(c)(6) and (c)(7)).
End
EconomicImpacts
Economic Impacts: Not applicable.
End
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Environmental Considerations: The recommendation does not constitute a “project” as defined by the CEQA Guidelines as the recommendation is a continuing administrative or maintenance activity and an organizational or administrative activity of the City that will not result in a direct or indirect physical change in the environment. (CEQA Guidelines sections 15378(b)(2) and 15378(b)(5)).
End
Sustainability
Sustainability: Not applicable.
End
Commission/Committee Action
Commission/Committee Action: None.
End
RationaleforRecommendation
Rationale for Recommendation: The City strives to ensure the qualification and evaluation standards prescribed for recruitment processes and practices are correctly and consistently applied to all applicants. Based on the information provided with Appellant Jurado’s application, Appellant Jurado did not meet the qualification standards as stated in the job announcement for this position.
End
FinancialConsiderations
Financial Considerations: Not applicable.
End
LocalBusinessEnterprise
Local Business Enterprise (LBE): Not applicable.
End