Legislation Details

File #: 2026-01870    Version: 1
Type: Discussion Item Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/7/2026 In control: City Council - 5PM
On agenda: 11/17/2026 Final action:
Title: [Contract Supplement] Staff Response Regarding Councilmember Proposal for Consideration – Illegal Dumping Program Gap Analysis and Supplemental Agreement with Mr. Security Camera Inc. dba MSC Integration for Recycling & Solid Waste Code Enforcement Illegal Dumping Camera Surveillance System 
Attachments: 1. 2026-01870 STAFF REPORT, 2. 2026-01870 SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIALS [Updated 11172026 @0230PM]
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

Title

[Contract Supplement] Staff Response Regarding Councilmember Proposal for Consideration - Illegal Dumping Program Gap Analysis and Supplemental Agreement with Mr. Security Camera Inc. dba MSC Integration for Recycling & Solid Waste Code Enforcement Illegal Dumping Camera Surveillance System

End

 

FileID

File ID: 2026-01870

End

 

Location

Location: Citywide

End

 

Recommendation

Recommendation: 1) Adopt a Resolution a) approving the recommendations provided in the Illegal Dumping Gap Analysis report developed in response to the Councilmember Proposal for Consideration on Illegal Dumping; b) authorizing the City Manager or designee to establish the Recycling and Solid Waste CLEAR (Cleanup, Legal Disposal, Enforcement, Awareness, Response) Group as a pilot program and add the following positions to the Recycling and Solid Waste Division of the Public Works Department: i) 1.0 FTE Integrated Waste General Supervisor, ii) 1.0 FTE Integrated Waste Supervisor, iii) 2.0 FTE Integrated Waste Equipment Operators, and iv) 5.0 FTE Maintenance Workers; c) make the necessary adjustments within the Solid Waste Enterprise Fund and Commercial Waste Compliance budget for the recommended labor, equipment, and service/supplies budgets as part of the FY26/27 operating budget to provide expanded services; and 2) pass a Motion authorizing the City Manager or designee to execute Supplemental Agreement No. 3 of 2025-0262 with Mr. Security Camera, Inc. dba MSC Integration for the purchase of five (5) additional camera systems and associated costs in an amount of $128,500, bringing the total contract not-to-exceed amount to $468,500.

End

 

Contact

Contact: Erin Treadwell, Waste Compliance Manager, etreadwell@cityofsacramento.org; (916) 808-4934; John Febbo, Division Manager, jfebbo@cityofsacramento.org, (916) 808-4949; Department of Public Works

End

 

Presenter

Presenter: Erin Treadwell, Waste Compliance Manager, etreadwell@cityofsacramento.org; (916) 808-4934; John Febbo, Division Manager, jfebbo@cityofsacramento.org, (916) 808-4949; Department of Public Works

End

 

Attachments

Attachments:

1-Description/Analysis

2-Resolution

3-Agreement

4-Illegal Dumping Gap Analysis Report

5-Budget and Audit Committee Report

6-Presentation [Updated 11172026 @0230 PM]

End

 

 

 

Additional Description/Analysis

IssueDetail

Issue Detail: On February 3, 2026, the Budget and Audit Committee (Committee) reviewed and approved a proposal introduced by Councilmembers Roger Dickinson, Mai Vang, and Caity Maple calling for a comprehensive benchmark review and gap analysis of how the City currently addresses illegal dumping. The Committee passed a motion directing the appropriate council appointing officer to commence work and forward the item to the City Council for consideration without further review by the Committee.

 

The Recycling and Solid Waste Division (RSW) has prepared the attached Illegal Dumping Gap Analysis, which evaluates existing mitigation activities and identifies opportunities to: improve reporting; legal disposal access; and response, education, and enforcement. The findings propose several actions to expand access to legal disposal services, improve the efficiency of illegal dumping response, and strengthen enforcement capabilities. Recommended actions include establishing dedicated staffing and equipment, improving coordination among existing services, expanding legal disposal capacity, evaluating additional enforcement tools, and deploying additional illegal dumping cameras. These actions will be launched as a pilot program in recognition of the fact that the actions recommended herein are less substantial than what would likely be needed to comprehensively address illegal dumping in Sacramento.  These recommendations are limited to what can be accommodated with existing Commercial Compliance funding, as articulated below.

 

Establish Coordinated Program Ownership: RSW recommends consolidating oversight of its public right-of-way illegal dumping response, legal disposal access programs, and street sweeping under a single operational structure within the proposed RSW CLEAR (Cleanup, Legal Disposal, Enforcement, Awareness, Response) Team. Currently, these functions are distributed across multiple workgroups and management responsibilities rather than managed as one coordinated program. Creating a formal program to be led by a new Integrated Waste General Supervisor would provide dedicated oversight, establish clearer accountability, improve coordination and resource deployment, and support consistent performance monitoring.

 

Establish Dedicated Small-Debris Response: RSW's field study found that approximately 14 percent of reported illegal dumping piles consisted of loose trash, small bags, and other hand-loadable debris that does not require collection by a tractor-mounted claw and rear-loader collection vehicle. Establishing two dedicated small-debris crews would allow RSW to deploy staffing and equipment appropriate to the material being collected, while preserving larger collection equipment for dumping piles that require it. The “Small Debris Collection Crews” would also conduct routine dumping hotspot checks and cleanups, remove smaller material remaining after bulky items are collected, and address hard-to-reach locations.

 

Expand Legal Disposal Access: RSW recommends increasing Household Junk and Appliance/E-Waste collection capacity to improve appointment availability and reduce customer wait times. The Gap Analysis also identified geographic convenience as an important consideration in Dump Coupon participation, with higher utilization among residents located closer to the historically available Fruitridge Road disposal facility. In July 2026, RSW expanded Dump Coupon acceptance to the North Area Recovery Station, providing an additional disposal location for north area residents. These improvements would make legal disposal services more accessible and support the City's broader illegal dumping prevention efforts.

 

Conduct Targeted Legal Disposal Outreach: Targeted education and outreach in neighborhoods where illegal dumping activity is comparatively high and use of available legal disposal programs is comparatively low would allow RSW to direct existing outreach resources to areas where increased awareness and participation may have the greatest effect. Outreach could include direct mailers, digital media, community events, and coordination with neighborhood organizations, with materials provided in languages appropriate to the communities served.

 

Update City Code to Expand Enforcement Options: The Gap Analysis identified limitations in the City's existing enforcement process, including challenges collecting assessed penalties and deterring repeat violations. RSW recommends working with the City Attorney's Office and appropriate enforcement partners to evaluate additional enforcement measures and determine whether City Code amendments or other legal mechanisms are warranted. Potential measures for legal consideration include vehicle impoundment or immobilization where authorized by law, business-license consequences for qualifying commercial violations, community service or cleanup restitution where legally available, additional mechanisms for addressing unpaid citations, and referral of appropriate cases to the Sacramento County District Attorney for consideration of criminal prosecution.

 

Improve 311 Illegal Dumping Reporting Workflow: Currently, the process to report illegal dumping in the public right-of-way through the 311 portal requires residents to navigate multiple service categories and selections before reaching the appropriate reporting form. Illegal dumping is currently listed under the broader Solid Waste category, making the service less intuitive to locate. Existing reporting fields also do not consistently capture the information needed for an efficient response, such as the exact location of a pile, pile size, material types, access conditions, and potential hazards. RSW is working together with 311 and the City’s Information Technology Department to modernize the reporting experience by simplifying navigation, reducing unnecessary clicks, and collecting structured information that supports accurate routing, appropriate crew deployment, and identification of duplicate reports. These improvements would make reporting illegal dumping faster and more convenient for residents while improving the efficiency of City response.

 

Expand Illegal Dumping Camera Program: Camera footage is essential to pursuing enforcement and building an illegal dumping case. Over 90 percent of illegal dumping piles do not contain any evidence for RSW code enforcement officers to investigate and attempt to identify the violator. On March 18th, 2025, City Council approved City Agreement No. 2025-0262 with Mr. Security Camera, Inc. dba MSC Integration for the purchase, installation, and on-going maintenance of 13 camera systems to monitor illegal dumping. Installing additional cameras at known dumping hotspots would expand RSW’s monitoring and investigative capability. The presence of cameras can also deter illegal dumpers from dumping at a site.

 

To begin implementation of the recommendations from the Illegal Dumping Gap Analysis, staff recommends approval of new staff positions to allow for the establishment of the RSW CLEAR Group and the Small Debris Collection Crews, and the execution of a supplemental agreement with Mr. Security Camera, Inc. dba MSC Integration for the purchase of five additional camera systems.

End

 

PolicyConsiderations

Policy Considerations: The recommendations in this report are in accordance with the following specific policies from the Sacramento 2040 General Plan:

 

PFS-5.1: The City shall reduce the amount of solid waste that is disposed in landfills by promoting source reduction and recycling throughout Sacramento and by expanding the range of programs and information available to local residents and businesses, consistent with State requirements.

 

PFS-5.2: The City shall provide for continued solid waste collection and recycling services in Sacramento, including contracting with franchise waste haulers, and ensuring adequate transfer station facilities capacity and the availability of adequate landfill capacity to meet future needs.

 

PFS-5.6: The City shall continue to provide programs that allow residential households to schedule two appointments per year for the collection of large refuse items.

 

PFS-5.8: The City shall continue to promote the safe disposal of household hazardous waste, e-waste, and batteries through public education.

 

PFS-5.9: The City may coordinate with franchise waste haulers to provide education, in appropriate languages, to property managers and building owners of commercial and multi-unit properties to implement best practices for waste diversion and reduce contamination.

 

Supplemental contracts exceeding 10% of the previous not-to-exceed amount must be approved by the City Council consistent with section 3.04.020 of the City Code when the original contract was more than $250,000, but less than $1,000,000.

End

 

EconomicImpacts

Economic Impacts: None.

End

 

EnvironmentalConsiderations

Environmental Considerations: This report provides recommendations to address illegal dumping, which impacts the health and safety of the environment.

 

California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA): No environmental review is necessary because the recommendations in this report involve administrative activity and are not considered to be a project in accordance with Section 15378(b)(2) of the CEQA Guidelines.

End

 

Sustainability

Sustainability: Illegal dumping affects the health and safety of the public and the environment. Illegally dumped hazardous waste such as tires, asbestos, sharps, and chemicals can contaminate soil, groundwater and drinking water, and surrounding bodies of water and waterways. Illegally dumped waste can also create fire hazards, clog creeks and rivers, and provide breeding grounds for vermin and insects that can carry diseases.

End

 

Commission/Committee Action

Commission/Committee Action: On February 3, 2026, the Budget and Audit Committee reviewed the councilmember proposal to conduct an illegal dumping gap analysis and passed a motion directing the appropriate council appointive officer to commence work on the proposal with committee members and forwarding the item to the City Council for consideration without further review by the Budget and Audit Committee.

End

 

RationaleforRecommendation

Rationale for Recommendation: The recommendations presented in the Illegal Dumping Gap Analysis were developed from field observations, analysis of City operational data, meetings with other City departments, benchmarking other jurisdictions, citation issuance and payment history, dumping patterns, and legal disposal program participation. The analysis identified opportunities to improve coordination among existing services, deploy collection resources more efficiently, expand access to legal disposal options, and strengthen enforcement capabilities.

 

The establishment of a formal, coordinated pilot program, additional staff and equipment resources, targeted education and outreach, reporting improvements, evaluation of additional enforcement options, and additional cameras would enable the City to increase Household Junk and Appliance/E-Waste collection appointments, educate residents on the legal disposal options available, provide more efficient illegal dumping and small-debris response, expand RSW’s illegal dumping monitoring program, and introduce meaningful enforcement tools to strengthen deterrence and accountability.

End

 

FinancialConsiderations

Financial Considerations: If approved, RSW will order the equipment and begin recruitment for the positions as soon as possible. The recommended expansion of legal disposal programs and enhancements to RSW’s public right-of-way illegal dumping response will be funded through the Commercial Waste Compliance operating budget (Fund 1001) and the Recycling and Solid Waste Available Fund Balance (Fund 6007) in FY2026/27. These sources will fund one-time capital costs to procure equipment and fund ongoing labor, operational, and disposal costs.

 

Costs for the recommendations have been split accordingly to comply with Proposition 218, and only eligible costs to expand legal disposal programs are funded using solid waste rate revenues.  The proposed expansion of the public right-of-way illegal dumping collection must be funded from commercial waste franchise fees.  Per Sacramento City Code section 13.24.260, commercial waste franchise fees may be used for the collection and disposal of waste related to illegal dumping on public rights-of-way and city property.  The FY2026/27 costs for each funding component are as follows:

 

Sufficient funding is available in the Recycling and Solid Waste Available Fund Balance (6007) and the approved FY2026/27 Commercial Waste Compliance Operating Budget (Fund 1001, Dept. ID 15005861) to fund the proposed program expansions and to execute the supplemental agreement with Mr. Security Camera, Inc. dba MSC Integration for the purchase of additional illegal dumping cameras.  Funding after June 30, 2027, will be subject to funding availability in the budget adopted for the applicable fiscal year. 

End

 

LocalBusinessEnterprise

Local Business Enterprise (LBE): Mr. Security Camera, Inc. dba MSC Integration is a Local Business Enterprise.

End