Title
Appeal of the Disqualification of Scott Leffingwell from the Aquatics Recreation Coordinator Recruitment
End
FileID
File ID: 2026-01996
End
Location
Location: Citywide
End
Recommendation
Recommendation: Pass a Motion 1) waiving formal rules for conducting the hearing pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4(11)(c)(7), and 2) adopting the Director’s findings, determinations, and decision of disqualification in the appeal of Scott Leffingwell for the Aquatics Recreation Coordinator Recruitment pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4.11(c)(6).
End
Contact
Contact: Abby Souza, Personnel Analyst, (916) 808-8907,
asouza@cityofsacramento.org, Human Resources Department
End
Presenter
Presenter: None
End
Attachments
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Job Announcement
3-Applicant’s Application
4-Notice of Disqualification
5-Appeal from Applicant
End
Description/Analysis
IssueDetail
Issue Detail:
BACKGROUND
A job announcement for Aquatics Recreation Coordinator posted on August 01, 2026 (Attachment 2). On August 02, 2026, Scott Leffingwell submitted a timely application (Attachment 3) for the posting. On September 21, 2026, Appellant Leffingwell received a notice of disqualification (Attachment 4) stating they did not pass the stated qualifications under the “Experience and Education” portion of the job announcement.
ISSUE RAISED BY APPELLANT
On September 22, 2026, Appellant Leffingwell submitted an appeal response (Attachment 5) to the disqualification, citing Civil Service Board (CSB) Rule 4.10(c)(1): Erroneous interpretation or application of the qualification standards prescribed for the classification. Appellant Leffingwell’s appeal states in part:
“I am writing to formally appeal the determination that my application for the position of Aquatics Recreation Coordinator, 016980-26-YPCE, did not reflect the required minimum qualifications. I respectfully request that the City of Sacramento review my application and qualifications again under Civil Service Board Rule 4.10(c), specifically on the grounds of an erroneous interpretation or application of the qualification standards prescribed for the classification. There is also a significant discrepancy in the determinations I have received regarding my eligibility for this position. On August 24, 2026, I received written notification from the City of Sacramento stating that I met the requirements for the Aquatics
Recreation Coordinator position and that my rank was #1. I have attached a copy of that correspondence to this appeal for the Civil Service Board's review. Because I was previously notified that I met the requirements and was ranked #1, I am respectfully requesting clarification and reconsideration of the subsequent determination that my application did not reflect the required minimum qualifications. These two determinations appear to be inconsistent, and I believe the August 24 notification provides important evidence that my
application and qualifications had previously been determined to satisfy the City's requirements….
In addition to the August 24 determination, I believe my professional background reflects substantial and directly relevant experience in aquatics operations, recreation programming, staff leadership, facility operations, financial management, regulatory compliance, customer service, and organizational administration….
I respectfully request that the Civil Service Board: 1. Review my submitted application, qualifications, and supporting documentation; 2. Review the August 24, 2026 correspondence confirming that I met the requirements for the position and was ranked #1; 3. Reconsider whether my education and professional experience satisfy the minimum qualifications for Aquatics Recreation Coordinator, 016980-26-YPCE; 4. Determine whether the subsequent screening determination resulted from an erroneous interpretation or application of the qualification standards; 5. Correct the screening determination if an error is identified; and 6. Permit me to continue in the examination. “
CITY’S RESPONSE TO APPEAL
The City contends the qualification standards prescribed for the classification were correctly applied to Appellant Leffingwell, and they do not meet the qualification standards as stated in the job announcement. The City responds to each item raised by Appellant Leffingwell, respectively, as follows:
I. The minimum qualifications for the classification that Appellant Leffingwell applied to are as follows:
a. EDUCATION and EXPERIENCE
Education
AA degree with major course work in recreation and leisure studies or directly related field.
-And-
Experience
Four years of experience to include two years of lead experience of an aquatic facility, and two years of seasonal guarding and lesson instruction.
Substitution
An additional two years of qualifying experience may substitute for the required education.
II. The City interprets and consistently applies the minimum qualifications to mean:
AA degree with major course work in recreation and leisure studies or directly related field AND two years of lead experience at an aquatic facility involving day-to-day functional guidance to employees. Lead responsibilities may include assigning, coordinating, prioritizing, and reviewing work; providing training and guidance; answering technical questions; monitoring workflow; and assisting with resolving operational issues. In addition, applicants must possess two additional years of lifeguarding experience involving monitoring aquatic activities, enforcing safety rules, responding to emergencies, providing swimming lessons and aquatic instruction, and performing other lifeguarding duties.
OR
Six years of experience of which must have included two years of lead experience of an aquatic facility, and an additional two years of seasonal guarding and lesson instruction if using the substitution pattern screening option.
III. Appellant Leffingwell’s application demonstrated they met the education requirement of an AA degree with major course work in recreation and leisure studies or directly related field through their supplemental question responses. However, the application did not demonstrate four years of experience which includes two years of lead experience of an aquatic facility, and two years of seasonal guarding and lesson instruction.
The two years of lead experience at an aquatic facility was not demonstrated through Appellant Leffingwell’s work duties listed in the application. Although the appellant demonstrated lead duties through their work experience at the Tri-County YMCA of the Ozarks, the duties listed did not verify that the lead experience was at an aquatic facility and therefore did not qualify for minimum qualifications component of “two years of lead experience of an aquatic facility”.
The appellant also failed to demonstrate the required two years of seasonal guarding and lesson instruction experience. In the work experience section for Aqua-Tots Chandler, Appellant Leffingwell stated they “Promoted numerous employees to water safety instructor level through on-going training and development” and “Promoted water safety instructor to aquatic manager through training/ mentoring”. These duties demonstrate involvement in training, mentoring, and developing employees for advancement into higher-level positions. However, they do not establish that Appellant Leffingwell personally performed lifeguarding or aquatic lesson instruction duties. While this experience may support the lead experience requirement, the information provided does not clearly establish that the duties were performed within an aquatic facility, as the responsibilities described could also be associated with administrative or programmatic functions. Additionally, the appellant did not demonstrate that they personally performed the two additional years of lifeguarding and lesson instruction duties required by the classification's minimum qualifications. Even if this experience was considered qualifying for guarding and lesson instruction experience, the employment dates listed for this position reflect only one month of experience, which does not meet the required two years.
No other work experience identified in the work duties section of application, for any employer, demonstrated experience performing guarding and lesson instruction or demonstrated two years of lead experience at an aquatic facility.
In their appeal response, Appellant Leffingwell provided additional information regarding their experience in aquatics operations, recreation programming, staff leadership, facility operations, financial management, regulatory compliance, customer service, and organizational administration. However, the additional duties and experience described in the appeal could not be considered in the minimum qualification evaluation. Minimum qualifications are assessed solely based on the experience documented in the duties section of the work experience portion of the application. Appellant Leffingwell answered yes to the supplemental question on their application (Attachment 3) indicating they understood they must list current and/or past job-related experience in the duties area of the work experience section of their application.

Additionally, the supplemental experience information submitted with the appeal could not be considered as the appeal response was submitted after the final filing deadline of August 22, 2026, and therefore could not be considered in accordance with Civil Service Board Rule 4.2, which states in part:
“Applicants for examinations must meet the qualification standards for the classification by the date set forth in the announcement. Any license requirements, however, shall be met at time of appointment.”
Therefore, the additional work experience information provided in their appeal
response could not be considered when determining whether Appellant Leffingwell met the minimum qualification for this position.
IV. In their appeal response, Appellant Leffingwell states, “There is also a significant discrepancy in the determinations I have received regarding my eligibility for this position. On August 24, 2026, I received written notification from the City of Sacramento stating that I met the requirements for the Aquatics Recreation Coordinator position and that my rank was #1. Because I was previously notified that I met the requirements and was ranked #1, I am respectfully requesting clarification and reconsideration of the subsequent determination that my application did not reflect the required minimum qualifications. These two determinations appear to be inconsistent, and I believe the August 24 notification provides important evidence that my application and qualifications had previously been determined to satisfy the City's requirements.”
To clarify, the ranking referenced by Appellant Leffingwell is a result of the Training and Experience examination, which consists of supplemental questions located at the end of the application. Responses to the Training and Experience exam are rated and scored, and those scores determine the applicant’s rank on the eligible list. The ranking itself does not represent a review or determination that the information provided in the work experience section of the application met the minimum qualifications for the position. Consistent with Step 2 (Training and Experience Exam) of the Selection Procedure outlined in the job announcement (Attachment 2), the establishment of the eligible list occurs prior to and separate from the minimum qualifications review.

As indicated in the Screening Committee section of the Selection Procedure, all candidates who pass the examination and are placed in one of the top three ranks will have their applications forwarded to the hiring department for review. The hiring department will select the most competitive applications for further consideration. Human Resources will evaluate applications for the minimum qualifications, as stated in the job announcement, only after an application has been selected by the hiring department. During this review, it was determined that Appellant Leffingwell’s submitted application did not demonstrate that the minimum qualifications were met based on the information provided in the duties section of the application.
Accordingly, Appellant Leffingwell’s rank placement reflects their examination
score only and does not indicate that their minimum qualifications had been reviewed or confirmed at that stage of the process.

V. Based on the work experience provided on the application, Appellant Leffingwell failed to demonstrate they met the minimum qualifications for the classification. As stated in the job announcement, and in alignment with Civil Service Board Rule 4.3 (a), Appellant Leffingwell is not eligible for further consideration as their application failed to demonstrate they met the minimum qualifications for the job announcement.
“Failure to meet any of the requirements or qualifications established for the examination, as published in the announcement.”
Appellant Leffingwell will have the ability to re-apply when this classification is recruited for again. Recruitments are conducted on an as-needed basis based on department needs.
VI. The same evaluation standards prescribed for the classification were applied to all applicants.
As such, the Director of Human Resources recommends that the Board adopt the Director’s findings, determination, and decision of disqualification pursuant to Civil Service Board Rule 4.11(c)(6).
End
PolicyConsiderations
Policy Considerations: Civil Service Board Rule 4.3 Disqualification (a) Failure to meet any of the requirements or qualifications established for the examination, as published in the announcement. Appeals for disqualification shall be heard by the Board unless the Board requests and receives permission from the City Council to utilize the services of a hearing officer. (Civil Service Board Rule 4.11). When the Board hears the appeal itself, the Board may waive the formal rules of procedure in the interest of justice in individual cases and
End
EconomicImpacts
Economic Impacts: Not applicable.
End
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Environmental Considerations: The recommendation does not constitute a “project” as defined by the CEQA Guidelines as the recommendation is a continuing administrative or maintenance activity and an organizational or administrative activity of the City that will not result in a direct or indirect physical change in the environment. (CEQA Guidelines sections 15378(b)(2) and 15378(b)(5)).
End
Sustainability
Sustainability: Not applicable.
End
Commission/Committee Action
Commission/Committee Action: None.
End
RationaleforRecommendation
Rationale for Recommendation: The City strives to ensure the qualification and evaluation standards prescribed for recruitment processes and practices are correctly and consistently applied to all applicants. Based on the information provided with Appellant Leffingwell’s application, Appellant Leffingwell did not meet the qualification standards as stated in the job announcement for this position.
End
FinancialConsiderations
Financial Considerations: Not applicable.
End
LocalBusinessEnterprise
Local Business Enterprise (LBE): Not applicable.
End