Title
Norwood Avenue - Alcohol Sales (P26-001) [Noticed 10/09/2026; Published 10/09/2026] [Continued from October 22, 2026]
End
FileID
File ID: 2026-01783
End
Location
Location: 4200 Norwood Avenue, APN: 237-0100-037-0000, District 2
End
Recommendation
Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing and upon conclusion, pass a Motion to: 1) close the public hearing; and 2) deny Conditional Use Permit to authorize the sale of beer, wine, and distilled spirits under a Type 21 License (Off-Sale General - Beer, Wine, Distilled Spirits) within an existing gas station convenience store on approximately 0.71-acres within the General Commercial (C-2-R) zone.
End
Contact
Contact: Deja Harris, Associate Planner, (916) 808-5853, dnharris@cityofsacramento.org; Zach Dahla, Senior Planner, (916) 808-5584, zdahla@cityofsacramento.org; Department of Community Development
End
Presenter
Presenter: Deja Harris, Associate Planner, (916) 808-5853, dnharris@cityofsacramento.org, Department of Community Development
End
Applicant
Applicant: Pete Tobin, Tobin Consulting, 7309 Marblethorpe Drive, Roseville, CA 95747
End
PropertyOwner
Property Owner: Ramanjit Virk, EDH Real Estate LLC, 1301 Souza Drive, El Dorado Hills, CA 95762
End
Attachments
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Background
3-Findings of Fact
4-Exhibit A: Project Plans
5-PCN Denial, 4200 Arden Way, File 671448, Sacramento Police Department
6-Community Comments
7-Presentation
End
Description/Analysis
IssueDetail
Issue Detail: The applicant is requesting a conditional use permit (CUP) to authorize the sale of beer, wine, and distilled spirits for off-premises consumption under a California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) Type 21 license at a 3,677 square foot convenience store within the General Commercial (C-2-R) zone. The convenience store is associated with a (Chevron) gas station, which consists of the convenience store, a carwash, and six fuel pumps, providing 12 fueling positions. Staff do not support the request to establish alcohol sales under a Type 21 license at this location. Staff recommend the Planning and Design Commission deny the project for the following reasons:
• The subject site is near multiple sensitive uses, including one income-restricted multi-unit housing development, two parks, three schools, and five assembly (e.g., church, community center, etc.) uses.
• The Sacramento Police Department has identified that over a five-month period between January to May 2026 there were 40 calls for service to the site and more than 1,300 calls for service within a 1,000-foot radius of the site.
• Alcohol sales for off-premises consumption at this site results in an undue concentration of establishments dispensing alcoholic beverage in this census tract (67.04). The Sacramento Police Department determined the public convenience or necessity (PCN) would not be served by the issuance of another ABC license at this location, and the Sacramento Police Department denied the applicant’s request for a PCN letter due to high calls for service, community opposition, and existing crime and blight concerns. Without an approved PCN, ABC will not issue the Type 21 alcohol license.
• Alcohol sales for off-premises consumption at this site is inconsistent with the 2040 General Plan policies and objectives. General Plan Map EJ-1 identifies the site as a disadvantaged community (DAC), and the 2040 General Plan discourages the establishment of unhealthy uses, like alcohol sales, in areas near schools, pedestrian priority areas, and disadvantages communities.
• The establishment of alcoholic beverage sales, at this location, is incompatible with surrounding land uses and contrary to the ongoing effort to improve pedestrian and multimodal conditions along Norwood Avenue as outlined in the adopted Norwood Mobility Plan.
Based on the information above and analysis outlined in the Background section of this report, staff cannot make the following findings and recommends denial of the project:
a. The proposed use and its operating characteristics are consistent with the general plan and any applicable specific plan or transit village plan (Sacramento City Code (SCC) section 17.808.200.C.1.a); and
b. The proposed use and its operating characteristics are not detrimental to the public health, safety, convenience, or welfare of persons residing, working, visiting, or recreating in the surrounding neighborhood and will not result in the creation of a nuisance (SCC section 17.808.200.C.1.d); and
c. The proposed alcoholic beverage sales will not adversely affect the peace or general welfare of the surrounding neighborhood (SCC section 17.228.108.A.1.a); and
d. The proposed alcoholic beverage sales will not result in undue concentration of establishments dispensing alcoholic beverages (SCC section 17.228.108.A.1.b).
End
Public/Neighborhood Outreach and Comments: As part of the application review process, the proposed project was routed to Robla Neighbors United, Robla Park Community Association, Rancho Del Paso Neighborhood Association, North Sacramento Chamber of Commerce, Preservation Sacramento, Civic Thread, Sacramento Area Bicycle Advocates, and Region Builders. Staff received no comments. Staff posted the site with an early notice at time of planning application submittal. Staff also mailed hearing notices to all property owners, residents, and neighborhood groups within 500 feet of the project site and posted the site 10 days prior to the public hearing. Staff received two letters of opposition from nearby residents opposed to alcohol sales in the community.
All comments received are included in Attachment 6.
PolicyConsiderations
Policy Considerations: The 2040 General Plan designation for the project site is Commercial Mixed Use (CMU). The 2040 General Plan recognizes that CMU designation areas are intended to foster vibrant retail and commercial centers of varying scales throughout the community.
Staff has determined the project is inconsistent with the following General Plan goals and policies:
Goal PFS-1. Responsive police and fire services that ensure a high level of public safety.
Policy PS-1.16 Development Review. The City shall continue to require new development projects to incorporate safety features and include the Sacramento Police Department (SPD) and the Sacramento Fire Department (SFD) in the development review process to ensure that projects are designed and operated in a manner that minimizes the potential for criminal activity and fire hazards and maximizes the potential for responsive police and fire services.
Staff Response: The proposed project is inconsistent with the goals and policy above in that the SPD reviewed the request for alcohol sales at this location and determined the public convenience or necessity (PCN) would not be served by the issuance of an ABC license at this location due to high calls for service, the proximity of nearby schools and churches, community opposition, and the adjacent intersection being a challenged location for crime and blight. Although the PCN determination is a separate process from this request, the concerns identified by SPD are directly related to the above policy, which calls for development projects to be designed and operated in a manner that minimizes the potential for criminal activity and maximizes public safety. The proposed addition of another off-sale alcohol establishment would occur in an area already experiencing documented police and crime-related concerns, with the SPD identifying over 40 calls to the location and more than 1,300 calls for service within a 1000-foot radius of the site from January 2026 to May 2026. While operational conditions may address certain individual aspects of alcohol sales and operations, staff finds that the concerns identified through SPD's review are broader site-specific public safety concerns. Accordingly, the proposed use is inconsistent with Policy PS-1.16 to ensure that development is designed and operated in a manner that minimizes the potential for criminal activity and supports a high level of public safety.
Goal EJ-2. Equitable access to fresh, healthy, and affordable food and wider access to healthy food resources in disadvantaged communities.
Policy EJ-2.16 Discourage Unhealthy Uses. The City should discourage the establishment of new drive-through restaurants, alcohol permits for off-site sales, and tobacco sales points near food deserts, schools, and pedestrian priority areas.
Policy EJ-2.20 Evaluating Health Impacts. The City may use best available data tools, including but not limited to Healthy Places Index, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) Social Vulnerability Index, and CalEnviroScreen, when evaluating health impacts from proposed projects in disadvantaged and historically underserved communities.
Staff Response: To be consistent with past practice and supported by Policy EJ-2.0, staff evaluated the requested alcohol sales using the best tools available relative to health impacts, including CalEnviroScreen and California Healthy Places Index.
• The General Plan and CalEnviroScreen identify this census tract (67.04) as a DAC. A DAC is defined as an area scoring in the top 25% of all California census tracts for pollution burden and socioeconomic factors as measured (SB 535). Key indicators in CalEnvrioScreen’s data include exposure to different types of pollution, environmental effects from nearby toxic chemicals, percentage of populations health and age sensitivity, and socioeconomic factors.
• According to California Healthy Places Index, this census tract has healthier conditions than only 20% of all other census tracts throughout the State of California (<https://www.healthyplacesindex.org/>). Considerations within the Index include economics, education, social, transportation, neighborhood, housing, clean environment, and healthcare access.
• Per ABC, this census tract (67.04) is overconcentrated with off-sale alcohol licenses, meaning that the ratio of existing licenses to population exceeds the ratio of licenses in the county.
• Map EJ-4 in the Environmental Justice Element of the 2040 General Plan has identified several the site as an underserved residential area with only one healthy food retailers (including supermarkets, supercenters, or larger grocery stores) within 1 mile, suggesting limited access to a healthy food retailer. It is more difficult to attract larger grocery stores in low-income areas due to less discretionary income.
• Research consistently shows that increased alcohol outlet density is associated with higher rates of alcohol-related harm, including violence, crime, and other public health issues. Studies have documented that, neighborhoods with higher densities of alcohol outlets, particularly in socioeconomically disadvantaged areas, experience a greater concentration of alcohol-related problems such as underage drinking, public drunkenness, and assaults.
Staff interprets Policy EJ-2.16, Discourage Unhealthy Uses, as applying to the request for new alcohol sales at this location. The applicant is requesting a new ABC license that will grant permission to sell beer, wine, and distilled spirits at the location. This expands the unhealthy use within the sensitive area, which is inconsistent with the goal of the policy to provide wider access to healthy food resources in disadvantaged communities.
North Sacramento Community Plan
The subject property is located within the North Sacramento Community Plan Area of the 2040 General Plan. The 2040 General Plan identifies the Community Plan Area as a welcoming community with working families and diverse neighborhoods, appealing housing options, and quick, convenient, accessible transportation connections to key destinations in the city. The North Sacramento Community Plan does not have any applicable goals or policies for the proposed use or subject site.
End
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Environmental Consideration: The project has been determined to be exempt from review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) because CEQA does not apply to projects which a public agency rejects or disapproves (CEQA Guidelines Section 15270(a)).
End
RationaleforRecommendation
Rationale for Recommendation: Staff recommends the Planning and Design Commission deny the requested entitlement for a Conditional Use Permit to authorize the sale of beer, wine, and distilled spirits. Staff is unable to make all of the necessary findings for approval as the proposal: 1) is not consistent with the 2040 General Plan; 2) is detrimental to public health, safety, convenience, or welfare of residents and visitors, and results in the creation of a nuisance; 3) adversely affects the welfare of the surrounding neighborhood; and 4) results in an undue concentration of alcohol beverages.
End