Title
Written Objections for Proposed Water and Wastewater Rate Adjustments
End
FileID
File ID: 2026-01553
End
Location
Location: Citywide
End
Recommendation
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution accepting the valid and timely received written objections to the proposed water and wastewater rate schedules for fiscal years beginning July 1, 2027, through 2031 and the City’s responses thereto, and determining that the City shall proceed with the Proposition 218 public protest hearing pursuant to the requirements of Government Code Section 53759.1.
End
Contact
Contact: Dalia Fadl, Director, (916) 808-3765, dfadl@cityofsacramento.org; Chuong (Ryan) Pham, Business Services Manager, (916) 808-8995, rpham@cityofsacramento.org; David Levine, Program Manager, (916) 808-6213, dlevine@cityofsacramento.org; Department of Utilities
End
Presenter
Presenter: David Levine, Program Manager, (916) 808-6213, dlevine@cityofsacramento.org; Department of Utilities
End
Attachments
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Resolution - Written Objections for Proposed Water and Wastewater Rate Adjustments
3-Exhibit A - Written Objections
4-Exhibit B - Written Objections Responses
5-Presentation-Written Objection Process
End
Description/Analysis
IssueDetail
Issue Detail: In accordance with Proposition 218 procedures, adopted by City Council in Resolution 2026-0219, the Department of Utilities (DOU) mailed notices to the record owners of each identified parcel upon which the proposed water and wastewater rates would be imposed. The notice included procedures for property owners and ratepayers to submit timely and valid written protests and written objections to the proposed water and wastewater service charges.
The number of written protests will be tallied and reported at the Proposition 218 rate hearing scheduled for the December 2, 2026, Utilities Rate Advisory Commission (URAC) meeting.
In addition to written protests, ratepayers that want to preserve their right to file a legal action challenging the water or wastewater rates must submit written objections to the rate adjustments. Objections were required to be submitted to the City Clerk’s Office by October 1, 2026, and the City was required to respond to each valid, timely objection in writing. The requirements for a valid objection and the deadline for objections to be submitted were detailed in the Proposition 218 notice sent to all property owners. The objections and the City’s responses must be presented to and considered by the City Council prior to the rate hearing. To be valid, written objections must be submitted in writing, be clearly labeled as a written objection, identify the affected parcel or account, specify the grounds for alleging noncompliance with the law, be signed by the record owner, a customer directly liable to pay the charge, or an authorized representative, and be received by the City prior to October 1, 2026, at 5:00 p.m.
In total, the City received 18 written objections, twelve of which were determined by City staff to be valid and timely.
Exhibit A to the Resolution includes all written objections submitted. Exhibit B to the Resolution provides responses to the written objections and explains why the water and wastewater rates are compliant with Proposition 218 and other applicable laws. The objections and responses are being presented to Council for its consideration, and staff recommend that Council, by resolution, accept the objections and responses and authorize staff to proceed with the Proposition 218 rate hearing on December 2, 2026.
...End
PolicyConsiderations
Policy Considerations: The City Council’s consideration of the written objections and responses is required by Resolution 2026-0219.
End
EconomicImpacts
Economic Impacts: Not applicable.
End
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Environmental Considerations:
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA): This action is not a project that is subject to CEQA because it is an organizational or administrative activity that will not result in direct or indirect physical changes in the environment. (CEQA Guidelines §15378(b)(5), 15060(c)(3)).
End
Sustainability
Sustainability: Not applicable.
End
Commission/Committee Action
Commission/Committee Action: Not applicable.
End
RationaleforRecommendation
Rationale for Recommendation: The City’s adoption of updated and increased water and wastewater rates is governed by Article XIII D, Section 6 of the California Constitution (Proposition 218). Under Proposition 218, the City cannot adopt updated or increased water and wastewater rates unless (1) the revenues derived from the rates do not exceed the funds required to provide water or wastewater services; (2) the revenues derived from the rates are not intended to be used for any purpose other than water or wastewater services; (3) the water and wastewater rates are calculated to proportionately allocate the costs of service to each customer class; (4) the services for which the rates are charged are immediately available to ratepayers; and (5) the water and wastewater rate revenues are not intended to be used for general government services.
The written objections submitted to the City primarily argue that (1) the City’s water and wastewater rates violate Proposition 218 and other applicable laws because the proposed rate structure allocates too many costs to the fixed component of the rates and because the water rates are uniform for all customers, rather than tiered for residential customers; and (2) the water and wastewater rate updates will unfairly impact low water users and low income customers. The City’s responses to these objections detail why these assertions are incorrect and the proposed water and wastewater rates comply with Proposition 218 and all applicable laws.
Courts have reviewed agencies’ water and wastewater rates to determine whether they comply with Proposition 218, and these decisions provide guidance regarding the limitations on potential rate structures and calculations. These decisions recognized that allocating the costs of a shared water system does not require a separate measurement of the cost of serving every parcel. Rather, cities may group customers with similar service characteristics into classes (i.e. residential, commercial, and multi-family) and use supported estimates to allocate costs among them. (Griffith v. Pajaro Valley Water Management Agency (2013) 220 Cal.App.4th 586, 601-602.) However, rates must be based solely on costs of service and not on other policy considerations, such as conservation or equity.
First, regarding the rate structure and the City’s use of a uniform rate, two courts have recently invalidated tiered water rates for residential customers on the grounds that they do not proportionately allocate costs. The courts in those cases stressed that agencies cannot put policy concerns, like water conservation, ahead of Proposition 218’s requirement that rates proportionately allocate costs to each customer class. Thus, the City properly structured its rates to reflect actual costs of service data.
While Proposition 218 does not permit the City to consider conservation when structuring rates, the City is a member of the Water Forum, which is a diverse group of business leaders, citizen groups, environmentalists, water managers, and local governments working together to balance the local needs for reliable water supply and environmental stewardship. The City’s water efficiency program is described within a portion of the Water Forum’s overarching agreement dedicated to the City and approved by all signatories. The City also recently completed an updated Water Efficiency Plan which was developed with stakeholder input through the Water Forum as a road map to meet the State’s water efficiency mandates. The City is currently meeting these mandates and expects increasing levels of water efficiency over time.
In addition, signatories to the Water Forum Agreement agree that operational, maintenance, and replacement costs should be recovered from beneficiaries of the system in accordance with California Government Code Sections 53720 to 53730 (Proposition 62) and California Constitution, Articles XIII, C and XIII, D (Proposition 218) and other laws to the extent they are applicable. Thus, while the City’s water and wastewater rates can only reflect actual costs, the City has demonstrated its commitment to conservation and water efficiency.
Second, Proposition 218’s requirement that rates be based only on costs also prohibits the City from structuring rates to benefit low water users or low-income customers. However, while rates must be set based on actual costs to be compliant with Proposition 218, DOU understands the community’s concerns around affordability and water use, and there are existing programs that are in place to address them.
The Sacramento Utility Rate Assistance Program (SURA), adopted by City Council in 2012, helps offset about 40 percent of income qualifying City of Sacramento utility customers’ bills. The program is funded by Measure U in the General Fund at $5.4 million annually and is subject to annual approval by City Council. SURA is not subsidized by other utility rate payers. With the proposed rate adjustments, DOU recognizes that SURA funding will also need to increase as more customers will need assistance. DOU will be seeking additional funding for the program from City Council.
End
FinancialConsiderations
Financial Considerations: Not applicable.
End
LocalBusinessEnterprise
Local Business Enterprise (LBE): Not applicable.
End